The value of multigenerational family living $$$

For twenty years, my Mom told me she never wanted to live with her children. They bought into a Continuing Care Retirement Community (CCRC) also referred to as “Life Care” Communities so they would “never be a burden” to their children. For those of you that have seen the first few years of my blog … helping my parents was a very complicated affair. I won’t say it was a burden, but we could have done it way better had we not tried to directly follow my Mom’s wishes.

I’m going to first share the cost of their care using the CCRC.

Non-refundable deposit to get into the CCRC $500,000 (1999)
This was in 1999 when that was how it worked.

Annual “rent” for their Independent Living apartment $ 38,400
This was the average cost from 2000 to 2012 for a total of $499,200.

At the end of 2012, the community required they move from Independent Living into the Assisted Living community. These were their “discounted” rates for their community since they paid the half of million to move in.

Annual cost for Assisted Living (for two) $117,600 (2013)
Dad passed away in 2013.

Annual cost for Assisted Living (for one) $ 94,800 (2014)
Annual cost for the required personal care
assistant for my Mom $ 98,208

Assisted Living was not the right place for my Mom with dementia. The residents didn’t want to eat with my Mom would couldn’t learn their names and my Mom stopped going to the dining room for meals. As you may know, there is no kitchen in Assisted Living and my Mom was unable to prepare her own meals. She became very agitated and so they required we hire a personal care assistant for 12 hours. The memory care community in the CCRC was only for end-stage individuals with dementia so neither the Assisted Living or the Memory Care were the right fit. We made the choice to move her to a Memory Care community outside of their “Life Care” community. So much for the HALF A MILLION they paid to move into this community.

Annual cost of Memory Care community $ 81,600 (2015)
Annual cost for the necessary personal care
assistant for my Mom $111,600

My Mom was unsteady on her feet after a medication put her in a state of delirium in 2015. She kept falling and ending up in the Emergency Room (ER). We hired someone who could help her use her walker and assist her and keep her out of the ER.

So at the end of this journey, my parents spent over $1.5 million. They saved and invested well so they had the money to pay for their care. But knowing what I know now, we could have used that money better to manage the last fifteen years of their lives.

As I sit here today with many of my clients in communities cut off from family and at a higher risk of getting covid, I realize I need to start having a discussion with my children. When we or one of us needs help, I hope my children will be able to make the best decision for us at the time they need to make it. No preset conditions because our world and how we will care for older adults is also changing.

For $1.5 million, I would have preferred to have a home where my parents could have lived with us, but still had the freedom to be independent. When they needed care, we could have arranged to bring it in. Thankfully, our community has gobs of ways to stay engaged and active and we could have used that money to pay for the personal care assistants to help them lead their lives when they needed it.

From 2012 through 2015, I was spending more than 20 hours a week helping them in one form or another. The last three years of my Mom’s life cost over $500,000. Had she been living with us, I could have spent more time being a daughter instead of a family caregiver, bill payer, medical support and care manager. I now know how to bring in the support to help fills these roles and that would have been much less expensive and I believe more joyful for me and my Mom.

This is the first time I sat down to add it all up. What I do know is that the current care solutions, whether in their own home or in a community, are not ideal for most of my clients right now. They are all very isolated and we don’t see this ending any time soon.

The reality is that things change and what is important today, may not be important tomorrow. So leave some space for adaptability.

Might it be time for us to move back to multigenerational homes and return to a personal model of caring for our loved ones? Advocated.

6 thoughts on “The value of multigenerational family living $$$

  1. I totally agree with multigenerational living. My parents also wanted to remain independent as long as they could. That meant my dad couldn’t properly care for my mom when she became septic. She was in a Nursing Home for rehab but insisted on going home when there was no medical or legal reason to keep her there. She kept “falling.” I told my dad to call the fire department if he couldn’t get her up and after so many visits in a week county social services stepped in. We were in the process of making me her POA when she died in NH. My dad floundered for a year. He fell prey to schemes and gave thousands of dollars away. My husband and I were able to talk him into moving in with us. It was hard but it was so much harder when he lived across town and I’d have to check on him every day and sometimes sneak in when he was gone to see what was happening with his bills and banking. It was a blessing to have him with us and he died very quickly but I was able to be there and hold his hand. I wish more people would see the good that can come from having family live together.

  2. Thank you for this post! I have often thought these past months that multi-generational living should be considered more as an option for our loved ones. I sure wish I (along with my husband) would have considered this as well for my parents.

    I have followed your blog for several years since I found much similarity with your situation and mine. My parents never wanted to be a burden, never wanted to be in a nursing home, wanted to be home. While it was not a burden, it was very difficult to manage their declining health conditions for both of them. And honestly, it didn’t turn out at all how they or I wished. And it all happened in the midst of raising a very active teenager with my parents initially 10 miles away at home and then 2 miles away after we lost dad. Although I look back at it all as a blessing of cherished time with them, I wish I could have a do-over as it could have been so much better….but we do the best we can do in the situation we are in. Knowing what I know now, I can fully understand how they felt. I clearly saw the inadequacies of senior independent living, assisted living, nursing care….and that was with me acting as nearly a full-time advocate. I just can’t imagine being in that situation now with the covid situation in the mix. My heart aches for so many isolated elderly.

    IF we had really been prepared and everyone would have been open to discussion, setting up our basement as an apartment for both my parents – and then just my mom – would have been such a wonderful solution. I suppose the good news….having gone through this….and my then teenager, now young adult….seeing and experiencing it as well….I think we can now have open discussions as we grow older of what may work best for hubby, me & child. Clearly, a multigenerational living situation could be a possibility. Your outlining all the financial & emotional costs in your post is much appreciated!

    1. Thank you! The events of late have made it very obvious that we need to not walk into retirement with fixed thinking. Everything has changed for so many people right now. I am surprised it took me so long to post this information.

  3. I 100 per cent agree with you.   Especially agree with this:  The reality is that things change and what is important today, may not be important tomorrow. So leave some space for adaptability. My Father lived in ALF for two years, had physical challenges, dementia worsened, moved over to thier Memory Care wing, broke his hip, moved to a DIFFERENT SNF and sadly passed away after 2.5 months. Yes, things change.  Yes, one must be able to adapt to the changes. If one has a choice, and has financial means, and is able to have their parent(s) live with, or nearby, them I think it is very worthy of consideration.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s